Democrats Just Took Congress. What Does That Mean for Student Loans?
Well, that escalated quickly.
Last week’s midterm elections delivered a pretty dramatic change in Washington. Democrats won control of both the House and Senate, including what appears to be a comfortable Senate majority.
For student loan borrowers, that raises an obvious question: could some of the more painful pieces of the One Big Beautiful Bill now be headed back to the negotiating table?
Maybe.
But don’t get too excited just yet.
Democrats were strongly opposed to the student loan provisions when the bill worked its way through Congress. Now they are about to control both chambers. But Trump still holds the veto pen, and his Department of Education has been enthusiastic about restricting graduate borrowing.
So, while the political equation has definitely changed, Democrats can’t just flip a switch and bring the old student loan system back.
Let’s take a look at what could realistically change, what probably won’t, and where borrowers may have a reason for optimism.
A Quick Refresher: What Borrowers Don’t Like About OB3
We’ve written extensively about the One Big Beautiful Bill, which I am going to continue calling OB3 because life is too short to type that name 25 times.
For graduate health professionals, four provisions stand out.
- Grad PLUS is going away: beginning July 1, 2026, Grad PLUS disappeared for new borrowers.Instead of being able to borrow federally up to the school’s cost of attendance, professional students are generally limited to $50,000 per year, while other graduate students are limited to just $20,500 per year.
- Many graduate health programs are stuck with the $20,500 limit: this one has created a mess of its own.Medical, dental and some other 4-year programs qualify for the higher professional-student borrowing tier. But several other graduate health professions do not satisfy the Department of Education’s definition of a “professional” program.And unlike the actual $20,500 and $50,000 limits, which were established by Congress, who qualifies for the higher category is something the Department of Education has considerable influence over through regulation and implementation.That distinction is going to become very important.
- Higher-income borrowers can pay substantially more under RAP: OB3 also replaces much of the current income-driven repayment structure with the new Repayment Assistance Plan, or RAP. The new formula becomes particularly painful for many of the graduate professionals we work with once their incomes climb above $100,000. And unlike some of the implementation questions surrounding borrowing, the basic RAP structure is written into the law.
- Forgiveness can take 30 years: for many borrowers, this is one of the biggest changes.RAP requires 30 years of repayment before remaining balances are forgiven, as opposed to 20 years under PAYE and New IBR. We’ve already counseled many veterinarians and APP’s who now have no chance of forgiveness. And again, this isn’t something a new Secretary of Education can simply decide to change.Congress wrote it into the law.
And then there’s the Department of Education itself. Technically, this isn’t an OB3 provision, but borrowers aren’t likely to care about that distinction. The Department of Education has gone through substantial staffing cuts and operational changes under the Trump administration.
At the same time, borrowers continue to encounter processing delays, repayment-plan problems and limited assistance when something goes wrong.That gives Democrats another issue to investigate once they take control of the congressional committees overseeing the Department of Education.
This all being said, the student loan debate in 2027 won’t just be about changing OB3. It may also be about how well the federal student loan system is functioning at all.
The New Political Reality
Here’s the good news for borrowers: Democrats don’t have to repeal the entire One Big Beautiful Bill to change its student loan provisions.
OB3 largely amended specific portions of the Higher Education Act. Congress can come back and modify those individual provisions without touching the rest of the massive law. Restoring Grad PLUS, raising loan limits, or updating RAP wouldn’t require repealing OB3. That makes targeted legislation much more realistic than an effort to dismantle the entire law.
But here’s the bad news: control of Congress is not the same as control of Washington. Assuming Democrats can keep their caucus together and satisfy Senate procedural requirements, they have the votes to move legislation through Congress. But they do not have the two-thirds majority necessary to casually override a presidential veto.
Trump remains president.
And sitting underneath him is an Education Department that appears philosophically committed to reducing federal graduate borrowing.
Meet the Players
President Trump
The Trump administration has repeatedly characterized the previous federal student loan system as too generous, too complicated and too expensive for taxpayers.
The administration has specifically blamed unlimited Grad PLUS borrowing for contributing to higher graduate tuition and has promoted the new caps as a way to pressure universities to reduce prices.
So, anyone expecting Trump to enthusiastically sign a bill recreating the Biden-era student loan system is probably going to be disappointed.
But presidents compromise. And I am not convinced every student loan provision in OB3 is a hill Trump is personally determined to die on. More on that in a minute.
Nicholas Kent
If you really want to understand where the current Department of Education stands on graduate borrowing, pay attention to Under Secretary Nicholas Kent. He has been remarkably direct.
Kent has argued that graduate borrowing restrictions will put significant downward pressure on the cost of tuition and prevent borrowers from accumulating insurmountable debt for degrees that don’t generate sufficient returns.
But the Department of Education has gone even further. Schools now have authority to impose loan limits below the federal maximum for particular programs, and the Department has encouraged institutions to consider doing exactly that under certain circumstances.
In other words, the people currently running the Department of Education aren’t reluctantly implementing these restrictions. They are on a mission they sincerely believe in.
Bernie Sanders
On the other end of the philosophical spectrum sits Bernie Sanders.
Sanders has advocated making public colleges and universities tuition-free and treating higher education more broadly as a public good. His College for All Act would make public higher education tuition-free for large portions of the population.
That’s about as far away from the Trump/Kent philosophy as you can get. If Sanders assumes leadership of the Senate committee overseeing education when Democrats take control, expect the student loan debate in that committee to look very different.
Bobby Scott
Robert “Bobby” Scott was one of the loudest House opponents of the OB3 student loan provisions. Even before the final bill emerged, Scott was warning that eliminating Grad PLUS and restricting federal aid could push borrowers toward unaffordable alternatives.
If he is again leading the House committee responsible for education policy, borrowers will have somebody controlling the agenda who already has a documented record opposing these provisions.
Elizabeth Warren
Interestingly, Elizabeth Warren isn’t on the Senate education committee. But that certainly hasn’t stopped her from weighing in.
Warren remains one of the most visible congressional voices on student loans and has already raised concerns about students being pushed away from federal loans and toward private lenders. She may not hold the committee gavel, but she has a large platform and isn’t likely to sit this fight out.
The List That Matters
Alright, enough politics.
Now that we know who controls what, let’s answer the question borrowers actually care about: what could really change?
1. Could Grad PLUS Come Back?
Our assessment: POSSIBLE, BUT AN UPHILL FIGHT
This is probably the most controversial borrowing provision in OB3.
Republicans eliminated Grad PLUS based largely on a straightforward economic theory: if the federal government stops allowing graduate schools to charge virtually any price and have students finance it with federal loans, schools will eventually have to lower their prices.
There’s just one problem.
So far, we aren’t seeing much evidence of that happening.
Take medical schools, for instance. We had AI check tuition rates for about 100 medical schools. While many institutions have not yet published their pricing for 2027/2028, it generally found no price reductions for the current A/Y. Many schools did, however, announce that they were freezing tuition for this year or next.
Furthermore, private lenders seem more than happy to fill the gap…especially in this high interest rate environment.
From what we are seeing at Student Loan Professor, private lenders have quickly stepped in to finance whatever amount students need to cover the cost of attendance. Practically every student we’ve worked with on this issue has been able to obtain approval.
That’s good news for the individual student. It may be bad news for the policy’s intended objective.
If schools don’t lower prices and private lenders simply replace the federal dollars that disappeared, then we haven’t reduced the cost of professional education. We’ve largely changed who finances it.
Healthcare workforce shortages may eventually add another layer of pressure. If policymakers begin hearing that federal financing restrictions are making it harder to produce physicians, dentists, advanced nurses and other healthcare providers, that argument may resonate with Republicans who aren’t otherwise interested in expanding student lending.
Still, bringing Grad PLUS back would require Congress to change the law and Trump to sign it or decline to veto it. That’s a substantial hurdle.
2. Could the Graduate Health Borrowing Limits Change?
Our assessment: THIS IS THE MOST LIKELY AREA FOR CHANGE
This issue has two separate components. First, there is the question of who qualifies as a professional student. That matters because a graduate student can generally borrow only $20,500 per year, while a professional student can borrow $50,000.
This is where the Department of Education has much more room to maneuver.
The definition and implementation of “professional degree” has already become the subject of litigation and regulatory controversy. The Department of Education has even had to alter aspects of its professional-program list following court intervention.
That means there are multiple avenues for change:
- The Department of Education could broaden its interpretation
- Courts could force changes to implementation
- Congress could intervene
- Political pressure from healthcare organizations could force reconsideration
This is especially important for programs such as PA, NP/DNP, CRNA, PT/OT and other graduate health professions. I consider this the most vulnerable portion of the new borrowing structure.
The second question is the actual dollar amount. Congress, not the Department of Education, established the $20,500 and $50,000 limits. Kent can’t raise those numbers. The Secretary of Education can’t raise them. A judge can’t simply substitute $75,000 for $50,000 because the judge thinks medical school is expensive.
Congress has to act.
That makes increasing the statutory limits significantly harder than expanding the professional-degree category. There is, however, a plausible compromise hiding in here.
Congress wouldn’t necessarily have to restore Grad PLUS for every graduate student in America. It could create higher limits or another borrowing exception specifically for expensive health-profession programs. Given nationwide healthcare workforce concerns, that may eventually be a politically easier sell.
3. Could RAP Payments Become More Favorable?
Our assessment: UNLIKELY UNDER THE CURRENT PRESIDENT
This one gets substantially harder. RAP’s basic payment structure is established by statute. The Department of Education cannot simply rewrite the formula because Democrats control Congress or because borrowers don’t like the resulting payments. Congress would have to pass legislation changing it.
That means we are back to the same obstacle: President Trump.
The Trump administration strongly supports simplifying the repayment system and moving away from the more generous repayment structures associated with previous administrations.
Could Democrats tweak RAP around the edges through bipartisan legislation? Sure.
But could we go back to something resembling the Biden-era repayment philosophy while Trump is president?
I wouldn’t bet on it. In fact, the RAP formula is quite favorable to those with high debt-to-income ratios and those making less than $100k. Though most of you reading this make (or will make) over $100k and are already feeling the impacts of RAP, no one is coming to the aid of “high income earners” anytime soon.
4. Could 20-Year Forgiveness Come Back?
Our assessment: UNLIKELY
This may be even more difficult politically. The 30-year forgiveness structure wasn’t an accident. Republican policymakers have repeatedly emphasized the idea that income-driven repayment should primarily be a repayment program, not a backdoor forgiveness program.
Reducing the term back to 20 years would therefore cut directly against one of the philosophies underlying the Republican reforms. And once again, the Department of Education cannot fix this administratively. Congress has to change the statute.
Personally, I’d put this lower on the probability list than modifications to graduate borrowing.
5. Could Borrower Service at the Department of Education Improve?
Our assessment: VERY POSSIBLE, BUT THIS IS A DIFFERENT FIGHT
This isn’t really an OB3 repeal question. It’s an oversight and operational question.
Once Democrats control the congressional committees overseeing education, they can hold hearings, investigate processing failures, subpoena information, pressure the Department of Education leadership and use the appropriations process to fight over staffing and resources.
That doesn’t guarantee borrowers suddenly get somebody helpful on the phone. But congressional control gives Democrats considerably more leverage to put the Department’s operational problems under a microscope.
It is also a budget question. One of the reasons Republicans/Trump/DOGE reduced staffing at the department (including half of the Ombudsmen team) was to help accomplish specific spending goals for the fiscal budget. A Democrat-controlled congress will have a massive impact here. They will look to cut funding in some areas while increasing funding in others. Will increasing funding for the Department of Education be on this list? We’ll have to wait until summer/fall of 2027 to find out.
The Wildcards
Politics has a funny way of ruining perfectly good predictions. So, there are a few things that could move our probability rankings considerably.
Trump cuts a deal: this might be the biggest one. Trump is clearly skeptical of large federal student loan balances. But I am less convinced he is personally attached to every technical piece of OB3’s student loan architecture.
If a bipartisan bill modifying professional-school lending reached his desk as part of a larger legislative compromise, would he really veto the entire package over a higher federal loan limit for medical students?
I doubt it.
Republicans change their minds: we haven’t identified meaningful Republican opposition to the core Grad PLUS and RAP changes during OB3’s passage. That could change once the provisions have real-world consequences.
If expensive graduate health schools don’t lower tuition, private borrowing increases dramatically (it already has), or particular regions begin complaining about healthcare workforce pipelines, Republican lawmakers may view the issue differently.
I actually think many Republics will compromise in this area and choose to stand their ground in other areas outside of student loans.
Lawsuits: lawsuits are definitely part of the story. They could materially change the Department of Education’s implementation of the professional-degree classification, and we already have what looks like a win for graduate-level nurses.
But courts aren’t Congress. A lawsuit can’t simply decide it would prefer $75,000 professional loan limits or 20-year RAP forgiveness when the statute says otherwise.
So while litigation matters, its scope is limited.
Democrats may decide they have bigger fish to fry: This one shouldn’t be ignored. While Republicans may be willing to back off on some of the new student loan provisions, Democrats could as well. Student loans were a major Democratic policy priority during the Obama and Biden eras.
But student loans weren’t exactly the centerpiece of the 2026 midterms.Voters appeared much more focused on the economy, affordability, Trump, government corruption and other major national issues. Democrats may have the power to fight over student loans. That doesn’t necessarily mean congressional leadership will spend its limited political capital doing so over the next two years.
The Big Picture
OB3 was constructed very effectively to reduce the federal government’s role in student lending. The law didn’t merely tell the Department of Education to go write some new regulations. Congress placed many of the most consequential rules directly into statute. And they put a bow on it by drastically limiting the powers of the Secretary of Education to forgive loans, pause payments, or change repayment plans. That matters!
Democrats just won control of Congress, but Trump is still president. Over the next two years we will only see substantial change if they decide to work together.
On a personal note, I want to acknowledge how triggering any discussion of politics can be. It’s never my intention to take sides, and I always try my best to keep these articles fair and free of any bias. I recognize that the most generous loan provisions for borrowers may not be what is best for taxpayers or fair for those without student debt. That is for each of us to decide and vote accordingly.
But one thing that becomes more apparent every year is that student loan policy is more politicized than ever. Borrowers must understand how power changes in DC impact their ability to fund their education and repay their loans. I believe political risk and volatility has become the number one hurdle to borrowers repaying their loans with confidence. So, I will continue to address these political considerations as needed to help ALL borrowers make informed decisions.
Brandon Barfield is the President and Co-Founder of Student Loan Professor, and is nationally known as student loan expert for graduate health professions. Since 2011, Brandon has given hundreds of loan repayment presentations for schools, hospitals, and medical conferences across the country. With his diverse background in financial aid, financial planning and student loan advisory, Brandon has a broad understanding of the intricacies surrounding student loans, loan repayment strategies, and how they should be considered when graduates make other financial decisions.


